17/08/2022
💡 Is being the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights an impossible job❓
➡️ In February 2018, URG Director Marc Limon published a blog on the early departure of the previous for , Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein. The blog examined the real underlying reason: the multifaceted nature of the High Commissioner’s mandate.
➡️ This theme has attracted renewed interest following the current High Commissioner, Michelle Bachelet’s announcement that she too will step down early. Marc Limon provides analysis again in a second blog on the role of the High Commissioner, reflecting on whether a single person can publicly criticise while also reaching out to them regarding or for agreement on key issues, for example, reform of the system.
In the blog, the case is made that the world needs both roles:
🔹 Quiet diplomacy, international and support to the machinery
🔹 Public advocacy and accusation of serious violations
The underlying question, then, is whether it is possible to have a High Commissioner assuming both roles at the same time. On this point, the following solutions are suggested:
👉 Limit the High Commissioner’s focus to public and the Deputy High Commissioner's role to
👉 Appoint different deputies for the three main roles of the mandate
👉 Create a new position (i.e., UN Human Rights Council’s Secretary General) for Secretariat functions
📚 Read the 2022 blog: https://bit.ly/3A0qFoR
📚Read the 2018 blog: https://bit.ly/3vA6V8G
In February 2018, I published a blog on the early departure of the previous High Commissioner for Human Rights, Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein. The blog responded to David Petrasek’s article in OpenGlobaRights entitled ‘Another one bites the dust’ (8 February 2018). The article attempted to look past...