09/26/2026
FORT YORK in Toronto is a relic of the defence of Canada during the War of 1812. But the defence of the U.S.-Canada border continued to be a concern well after the end of that war.
Carl Benn, formerly Chief Curator of Toronto History Museums, now Professor of History at Toronto Metropolitan University, recalls this concern:
“The fact that Fort York was maintained so late in the nineteenth century partly overthrows the myth of the "undefended border" between Canada and the United States in the post-War of 1812 period. Even beyond the end of Fort York's defensive ca-pabilities, Canada faced the prospect of war with the United States as late as the Anglo-American clash over the Venezuelan boundary in 1896. There also was some worry over a military threat centred on the Alaska boundary dispute of 1903; in the 1920s, defence planners thought about how to defend the country should the United States invade at the behest of American industrialists wanting to secure access to Canadian raw materials.” [Carl Benn ‘Historic Fort York 1793-1993’ (Natural Heritage / Natural History Inc. 1993) pp 132-3]
Andrea Charron, Director of the Centre for Defence and Security Studies, University of Manitoba, considers the advantages of preparing for black swan events, the consequences of failing to prepare and the fact that preparation is rarely a waste of time and resources (“Canada must consider even unlikely threats including an American invasion” published in The Conversation, 24 Sept, 2026.):
“…Canada has a long history of planning for unlikely but consequential scenarios. During the period between the First and Second World Wars, Canadian military planners developed Defence Scheme No. 1, which considered the possibility of conflict with the U.S. American planners, for their part, developed War Plan Red — a scheme to invade Canada in the event of a war with the United Kingdom. Neither expected war, but both recognized the importance of understanding strategic options. During the Second World War, the United States-Canada Basic Defence Plan (referenced as the Black Plan) was penned by Canada to respond to a scenario should Germany defeat the U.K., leaving Canada and the U.S. vulnerable to the Axis powers.”
Illustration: 'Cold Comfort' by Toronto artist Charles Pachter, acrylic and pencil on canvas, 1983.