08/09/2026
ISAAC SIMMONS
A MAN WHO ACCIDENTALLY NAMED A TOWN
+ LOOKING FOR A PHOTO OF ISAAC
In 1867 the Dandenong State Forest was created as a timber reserve, which only gave it limited protection as many timber workers and prospectors plied their trade there and it only meant that they weren't allowed to live there. By 1878, just 11 years later, large tracts of the Dandenong State Forest were excised and opened for settlement. The newly opened areas went on to become The Basin, One Tree Hill, Tremont, Upper Ferntree Gully, Upwey, Tecoma, Belgrave (also South and Heights), Selby and Menzies Creek. The State Forest Reserve was further reduced by the village settlement scheme of 1893.
In between the years of 1878 and 1893, timber workers looked through the remaining forest for suitable trees to harvest. In the 1880s one such man was Isaac Simmons. He found a patch of blackbutt particularly suitable for palings which he harvested. In 1893 when that portion of the Dandenongs became part of the new Monbulk Parish settlement, the selectors found a grassed cleared area close to where The Patch Store is now located which was the area that Isaac had worked. The locals started calling the area "The Patch" and by about 1900 it began to become officially used to describe the locality.
Isaac and Harriet Simmons and their family remained in the area and in July 1894 Isaac selected land in the Scoresby Labor Colony (One Tree Hill settlement), which became the origins of Ferny Creek. His selection, Lot 56, was in the far bottom corner of the colony however, at the junction of Sandells Road and Terrys Avenue, which is today in the Tecoma or Belgrave area. His 25 year old son Thomas (1869-1943) also selected the adjoining block, 56A, at the same time. In 1906 Isaac transferred Lot 56 to another son Joseph (1878-1952) and in October 1906 Joseph allowed Belgrave timber miller John Mahony to establish a mill on his land which stood for about 3 years before moving to the trestle bridge. Another adjoining block, 57, was also of interest to Isaac and he tried to obtain it in 1897. In 1898 block 57 was granted to William Anderson, who had married Isaac's daughter Martha in 1893, so it is likely that Isaac played a part in getting it.
The Simmons family history is a little hard to follow on Ancestry as there are some conflicting records. George Simmons (1811-1872) had married Sarah Sweatman (1800-1852) in 1833 and they had three children - Mercy (1833-1913), Thomas (1837-1919) and Isaac (1844-1927). Another daughter, Agnes, was born in 1852 (the same year that Sarah died, although she is recorded as the daughter of George's second wife Maria, which seems unusual as they weren't married then). George remarried after Sarah died to Maria Ferrer (1806-1870) in 1854. The family migrated from England to Aldinga in South Australia about 1858, but Mercy remained in the UK as she had married by then. Both George and Maria lived in Aldinga until they passed away in the early 1870s.
Isaac moved to Victoria about 1867 and married Harriet Ward (1843-1911) that year at Portland. Their first child, also called Harriet, was born in the Shire of Berwick in November 1867. The Shire of Berwick then included the Ferntree Gully area so they may have already been nearby. Isaac and Harriet had 9 children and they all remained in the wider area. Isaac was illiterate (signing with an 'X') and Harriet would deal with correspondence. Isaac died at Northcote in 1927 and was buried at the FTG Cemetery with Harriet. Isaac's older brother Thomas also moved to Victoria about 1869. Thomas had married Grace Morrish in Adelaide in 1860 with their first five children born in South Australia and the rest around the Cockatoo area where Thomas and Grace settled in 1873. Thomas died in 1919 aged 81 and was buried in the Nangana cemetery at Macclesfield.
Isaac's younger half sister, Agnes, is a bit more of a mystery as there are conflicting stories of how she came to Victoria. She became prominent around Melbourne in the 1880s supporting the suffragette movement, running a women only gymnasium in North Melbourne and being a swim instructor at Hegarty's Baths. She teamed up with Miss Geraldine Minet, a lady of means, and they started a failed coal mining venture at the Red Bluff in St. Kilda which became a book 'Enchanted Beneath The Bluff' by Isaac Hermann and Heather Arnold. Agnes lived in St. Kilda but when the 1890s depression hit she chose block 16H in the Parish of Monbulk, which was above Cooks Corner in Kallista, where Christian Grove is now. Agnes eventually moved to the block in about 1902 and remained in Kallista until her death in 1929. She was buried at FTG cemetery in the same plot as Alfred Simmons (1863-1928), who was her nephew, the son of her half brother Thomas. Agnes also featured in the ABC documentary 'Q***r Australia' and we did a post about her a few years ago.
While we have images of Thomas and Agnes, we have never seen a photo of Isaac, for whom we would love to find one of as the person who caused The Patch to be named as such. We have seen photos of other members of Simmons family, and the Anderson, Speedie, Charman etc families that are related by marriage so we are sure that Isaac must have been photographed at some stage.
One photo that we do have identified but does not seem to be identified anywhere else, although it even appears in the State Library archives, is one of brothers Thomas and Joseph Simmons, Isaac's sons, working in Sherbrooke Forest. The photo was taken in 1904 by Fitzroy photographer Erasmus Bede Allan and published in his book 'Tourists' Guide To The Dandenong Mountains' which was published in September 1904. Thomas and Joseph were identified in a 1960 newspaper article in the Free Press and are the only photos we have seen of them.
With many descendants of Isaac Simmons still around, hopefully someone will have an image.