08/10/2026
As we prepare to hang the next round of streetside banners, we continue to hear from people who have been inspired by the stories of Ovid’s past citizens and businesses. Stories that remind us that we can reclaim Ovid from the rubble of the fire and step out into the future. Stories that inspire us to envision our business district as a thriving, bustling community center. But mostly, stories that bring us together through a shared love of what we once had and what we hope to restore.
At our Founder’s Day celebration last Saturday, one of these stories was very eloquently written and read by Colleen Brackett, whose family sponsored a banner in honor of Mary Maher. Colleen’s closing words: “We have always found our way back” can be used to sum up not just her talk, but where we’re at in Ovid right now: we have ALWAYS found our way back, and with hard work and determination, we will again.
We’ll let her tell you the story in her own words:
Our mother’s name was Mary Maher and at one time, her store…Mary Maher’s Store…was a busy hub in the thriving community of Ovid. She owned and ran her store from about 1939 until 1951.
As a young woman, our mother got a job in a clothing store run by the Pitcher family. The store sold basic clothing for women, men and children. About 1939, the Pitcher family could no longer run the store. In stepped young and creative Mary Maher. She was able to buy the store and business at a time when there were very few women owned businesses. This was also a time when people shopped in their home towns. They didn’t go to Rochester or even Geneva. They shopped locally. Mary loved clothes. She loved the latest styles and was happy to bring these to the people of Ovid. She went on buying trips to NYC. She sold Polly Flinders dresses for little girls and fur coats for their mothers. Our cousin remembers shopping for dresses in the store with her mother and sister. Another cousin remembers going to the store with her mother. Her mother bought a tailored sky blue suit.
Our mother ran the store through the war years. She lived in the apartment above the store. She, the store and the town thrived and prayed for peace to come again. Then came the end of the war. The GI’s returned to Ovid. They were exuberant happy times. People continued to shop in town. Our mother and father fell in love and married. Our mother continued to run the store and they lived above it.
I was born in Ithaca and lived the first three and a half years of my life in the apartment above Mary Maher’s Store. I have memories of that wonderful time. Main Street was my front yard. I was allowed to play on the street out in front of the store. I was friends with everyone who walked down the street. Our family and friends lived and worked all around our mother’s store. Our Aunt Agnes Potter was down the street in the Post Office. Our Uncle Fred ran a grocery store that would eventually be owned by the Spencer family. Millis’s restaurant was right next door to our mother’s store. Our Aunt Clara Hughes worked across the street and she would often take me to the restaurant for a breakfast of mashed bananas and toast. Our Uncle Dick was around the corner at Hughes Meat Market. Our Aunt Mill lived down the street over the funeral home. Our grandmother and our Aunts Jean and Mary lived on Depot Road. Our mother’s good friend, Helen Mannix lived around the corner. When they say that it takes a village…that was true. Main Street in Ovid was my village and my playground.
All of this time my mother continued to run the store with the help of Evie Marks. Evie was both store clerk and kid wrangler. Our father worked at the Market Basket and at Willard. Then in 1951, he was hired as a Corrections Officer at Greenhaven Correctional Facility in Pauling, New York. It was time for our little family to move on. By that time, my little brother Eddie was joining the company. It was time for Mary Maher’s Store to close its doors. It was sold and it was run by a couple of different proprietors before it finally closed its doors as a clothing business.
Mary Maher’s Store was a part of an exciting time in Ovid’s history. I think that I can speak for my brother and our children and grandchildren when I tell you how proud we are of Mary Maher Nicholson and of Ovid. We have all gone in separate directions but we have always found our way back.
Thank you, Colleen and Ed, for believing in Ovid ❤️