08/06/2026
This opinion editorial was published in the Portland Press Herald this week.
Serious question: Given the fact that the Maine Legislature has demonstrated precisely zero fiscal restraint, has dramatically increased the state’s budget by 45% since 2019, and has provided a profoundly underwhelming return on the spending, why should we trust the money will be spent wisely, meaningfully, and honestly?
Why should more hardworking Mainers — even those in an anomalous cohort — surrender more of their hard-earned money to the Maine government after we’ve witnessed its egregious spending habits and abysmal fiscal management for the last eight years?
To be clear, Maine Policy Institute has not only been opposed to this surcharge tax, but to taxes affecting all Mainers in general.
In 2025, Governor Janet Mills and the Maine Legislature passed a slate of new taxes that affect ordinary, working Mainers, taking more of their money to be used for — what, exactly? To help Mainers, or to fill some budgetary shortfall created by lawmakers in Augusta? In any case, we opposed those taxes, too — not to mention the limitless spending. To compound the offense, Governor Mills had made hollow campaign promises not to raise taxes, and sure enough…
The reality is, as with most or all “progressive” ideas, taking more money from Maine taxpayers and throwing it at various issues to ostensibly benefit Mainers is, at this point, rooted in unrealistic and utopian fantasies, given our state government’s track record with spending and fiscal mismanagement in the last eight years.
It's truly no wonder why so many Mainers perceive Maine as unaffordable, and why some are considering leaving the state altogether.