05/25/2023
The Pharaonic Paradigm
It is the 24th of May in the US. My day begins with yet another heart-rending image, in a series of horrific images that we as ex-pats must see for the love of our land compels us; Shireen Mizari, a woman of principles, courage, a strong voice for human rights, and the most highly educated (all genders inclusive) ex-minister of Pakistan is forced to leave not just PTI but all politics.
I am drawn to the Pharaonic Paradigm. Those familiar with the Quranic Divine Speech, even at a very cursory level, know there is no paradigm, a pattern in the human psyche, individual or collective, which will persist as the Pharaonic. But first, what and why of this paradigm; what did Pharaoh exemplify? And so the question arises what did Moses stand for? God presents the two as two people of opposing stances; the former has allegiance to the SELF, Moses to The Truth-Justice-Reality-God. I use hyphenation because the Arabic word ‘Al-Haqq’ encapsulates the semantics of the Ultimate Principle, the Divine. As to why one wonders, God sees it necessary to bring this narrative up so many times in His Speech, although each instance appears to highlight a different aspect within a specific context.
In our contemporary language, the term closest to the Pharaonic Paradigm is Narcissism. When the love of the Self turns into worshipping the Self. When one does not stand for principles of truth, justice, reality, one is standing in opposition to God. One becomes the earthly god, the false god. Its contrary is the Mosaic stance. When one speaks up for truth, for justice, and hence for Divine Principles, one is standing up for the transcendentals, what is high above us in sanctity and honor. These principles are granted to us as Divine gifts in our very innateness. Even a child has a sense of fairness and unfairness, of truth and falsehood. But we get corrupted within our families, within our societies. We start compromising on these innate principles, diluting truth, covering up or falsifying truth. In doing so, we become unjust. And when we make a habit of it, we get better at it. We realize we can get for our SELVES what we want through aggression, coercion, manipulation, falsification, and deception, all of which are species of ugliness. This SELF-SERVING ugliness.
The mosaic stance, on the other hand, is a paradigm when a human being rises above Self-serving attitudes and stands up for principles of Truth and Justice. In doing so, the human being is standing with Beauty-God. Often, we approach the narratives of the Quran as stories of the past, which God explicitly corrects. So, the Pharaonic-Mosaic discourse shall persist throughout human existence. We have the potential of both. And often, I believe we are in every moment somewhere in the continuum between the two polarities of the Self-serving stance and the principled stance.
We all have within our psyche the potential of the Pharaonic stance, or its contrary, the Mosaic stance. Our very short journey on this earthly life is the actualization of the Mosaic stance and our opposition to the Pharaonic. Hence, the famous prophetic saying that jihad bi’al nafs is the biggest struggle. The battle with the Pharaoh within, the ‘I’.
It is not a story of the bygone era. It is my story and yours and that of every human being that will tread this earth. We all are in this battle every moment. It is the most intimate, uniquely personal, critical struggle of all. Yet, it is the most universal. Each one of us is a unique being in unique contexts and situations. In that sense it is particular, but because we all go through it, it is universal. The fact is, this enduring human struggle will be the making a Moses and of a Pharaoh within us. This is the ultimate battle.
Now, as we return to Shireen Mizari and every one of those who stood up for the principles of social justice, desiring a fair and just society, all equal under one law, equal human rights; right to self-determination, equal dignity of every human being, the rights of the weak and the underserved. We also see those subjugating the weak and defenseless women, children, elderly, sick, mentally or physically challenged---no exemption---through blackmail, force, oppression, tyranny, and lies. Pharoah threatened to crucify those who dared to question his authority. We see the living Pharaonic paradigm at its height in current Pakistan. But let us not distance it for our convenience. We are in this discursive battle in every waking moment of our lives.
I learned that to date more than 10,000 human souls who chose to stand up for social justice, to raise their voices, are locked up tyrannically by today’s Pharaohs. We each have a right to our personal voice. A voice that originates deep within my soul after the tribunal within adjudicates and forms a reasoned judgment. What gives anyone a right to take that away? If God had wished, he could have everyone believing in Him. But He chose to grant us the Human Will. This means, that the Divine granted us the right to determine whether I will prostrate before Truth-Justice-Reality-Beauty that is God. Or, whether I will choose to prostrate before my ‘Self’. Whoever takes these Divinely granted rights away, has tread too far on the Pharaonic Way.