05/09/2026
Aug 30, 2016 Mark Hays last seen,
Sept 26, 2016 Suzen Cooper murdered, Grigsby Ford Road
Oct 14, 2016 .22-cal rifle recovered from well, Sand Road
Oct 27, 2016 Sherman sentenced 24 months for supervised release
violations
Nov 4, 2016 Hays body found, Perla Dump Road
Jan 1, 2017 Mike Cash sworn in as sheriff
Feb 2017 Rachael Cooper arrested, first-degree murder
July 23, 2017 K9 Luky found dead — blunt force trauma (gunshot-admission on body-cam)
Aug 23, 2017 Rachael Cooper plea: murder → hindering, 25 years (Williams' court)
Nov 14, 2017 FBI Evidence Recovery Team excavates Hays scene
July 26, 2018 Donald Smith arrested for Cooper murder
Aug 2018 Cooper's body found, Grigsby Ford Road
July 2019 FBI Grindr sting catches counselor Jonathan Williams
Sept 3, 2019 Federal grand jury indicts Smith & Sherman
Jan 14, 2020 Jonathan Williams arrested by FBI
Dec 4, 2020 Deputy Winberry excessive force incident #1
Aug 15, 2021 Deputy Winberry excessive force incident #2
Aug 27, 2021 Winberry resigns amid FBI investigation
Sept 21, 2021 Smith & Sherman convicted at federal trial
~Jan 2022 Rachael Cooper paroled after ~5 years
May 11, 2022 Smith & Sherman sentenced: life, no parole
June 21, 2022 Jonathan Williams sentenced: 15 years
July 2022 Hays ballistic evidence finally submitted to crime lab (6-
year delay)
Fall 2022 JDDC investigation of Judge Williams begins (Case
22-328)
Nov 2022 Crime lab confirms ballistic match in Hays case
Jan 2023 Finkbeiner takes office as sheriff
April–May 2023 Group 6 conducts 7 controlled buys at Kenneth
Smith's Perla home
June 2023 Finkbeiner withdraws sheriff's office from Group 6 Task Force
Aug 2023 FBI surveils Kenneth Smith; Finkbeiner tries to stop investigation
Sept 2023 Anthony Williams arrested for Hays murder
Nov 2, 2023 Finkbeiner arrested by FBI
Nov 17, 2023 Montgomery arrested for Hays murder
Dec 18, 2023 Kenneth Wayne Smith pleads guilty
Jan 6, 2024 Both Judge Williams + Judge Shirron recuse from Montgomery case
March 30, 2024 Judge Williams "resigns" / removed from office
April 2024 Finkbeiner arrested again (state charges)
May 28, 2024 "Big Shelby" Montgomery Sr. murdered at Sand Road — the same address where murder weapon was recovered
Oct 8, 2024 Rachael Cooper re-arrested for drug possession
Feb 6, 2025 Finkbeiner arrested for witness tampering
Feb 14, 2025 Finkbeiner pleads guilty; resigns as sheriff
May 2, 2025 Finkbeiner arrested fourth time
May 21, 2025 Montgomery convicted, 40 years
Aug 20, 2025 Finkbeiner sentenced: 24 months (Judge Hickey)
Aug 21, 2025 Kenneth Wayne Smith sentenced: 37 months
Oct 27, 2025 Judge Shirron orders JDDC press release hung beneath Williams' portrait
Dec 1, 2025 Winberry sentenced: 24 months (Judge Hickey)
Feb 6, 2026 115 lbs m**h seized on I-30, mile marker 88, Dallas→Little Rock
Send a message to learn more