06/15/2020
Today RTC provides the following thought leadership on a recent action taken by Mayor Muriel Bowser for the District of Columbia.
Question: Whether it is constitutional for the mayor of the District of Columbia, using taxpayer funds and acting under and within her power and authority as mayor, to paint on the public street leading to the White House, the expression that Black Lives Matter?
Just recently Mayor Bowser was in the news. Using taxpayer’s funds (emphasis added) she instructed county workers to paint in giant yellow letters down the city’s 16th Street near the White House, the slogan “Black Lives Matter” on the public street.
One reason Respect The Constitution (RTC) organization was established was to hold politicians accountable to their oath as expressed by RTC’s guiding principle "Rise above politics to hold our elected representatives to their oath to respect the principles of the Constitution ".
Has Mayor Bowser violated her oath of office? Quite frankly yes.
At its core, the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution functions as a constitutional guarantee that no person or group will be denied the protection under the law that is enjoyed by similar persons or groups. In other words, persons similarly situated must be similarly treated. Equal protection is extended when the rules of law are applied equally in all like cases and when persons are exempt from obligations greater than those imposed upon others in like circumstances. The courts use a strict scrutiny test to enforce the principles of the 14th Amendment.
Mayor Bowser cannot satisfy the strict scrutiny analysis, because her arbitrary classifications are not narrowly tailored measures that further compelling government interests as the public street expression only applies to “Black Lives”.
Actually, RTC would submit that the name Black Lives Matter is discriminatory on its face as it only pertains to one class of lives and because it 'shows favoritism towards one race.
The 14th Amendment principles demands that government officials have the perspective that “All Lives Matter” (no suspect classification emphasis added). Without doubt, the actions of Mayor Bowser are unconstitutional. RTC would encourage all citizens to hold all politicians accountable by applying the strict scrutiny analysis to all government actions as you go through your daily activities.