09/23/2026
I-94 PRESEASON RANKINGS | #7 COLUMBIA TIGERS 🐅
Columbia showed us two completely different basketball teams last season.
One version looked capable of playing with anybody in the area. The other left you wondering how the same group could look so different from one night to the next.
The Tigers finished 17-12 and reached the Elite Eight, eventually falling to Fleming Island, a team that went on to play for a state championship. Along the way, Columbia had enough quality results to prove its ceiling. They split meetings with Buchholz, The Rock and Williston, while also picking up a win over Bradford.
But that résumé tells the other side of the story, too.
WHICH COLUMBIA ARE WE GETTING?
Columbia could beat a quality opponent one night and look completely outmatched against another one.
They were beaten 60-35 by Buchholz, then later came back and beat the Bobcats 40-38. They were beaten 55-37 by The Rock, then turned around and beat The Rock 73-63. Continue—->
That’s a massive swing.
Even some of Columbia’s better wins weren’t always convincing. They had close games against teams they were capable of separating from, and that inconsistency is ultimately what keeps the Tigers at No. 7.
Because talent isn’t really the question here.
THE PIECES ARE STILL THERE
Columbia graduates four seniors, including big man Terrence Tolbert, but plenty of important production remains.
They return their leading scorer, experienced guard play and multiple pieces from the rotation that made last year’s Elite Eight run possible. Kadrian Wilson gives them another versatile piece on the wing, and there’s enough size and experience around this group that Columbia shouldn’t have to completely reinvent itself.
That’s what makes them interesting.
The floor is already established. Now Columbia has to raise its ceiling.
The Tigers don’t need to prove they can win basketball games. They did that last year. They need to show that their best version can become their normal version, especially when the competition gets tougher.
At No. 7, they’re sitting right in the middle of this ranking for a reason. We can absolutely see Columbia climbing.
But the teams ahead of them have gi