19/04/2026
An obituarist of the former Prime Minister, Andrew Bonar Law (1858-1923) recalled the emotional burden of the ‘terrible sadness’ he bore whilst carrying out his state duties as Chancellor of the Exchequer in the wartime coalition government.
His two sons, Charles John Law and James Kidston, were both killed on active service during 1917. Bonar Law's loss was a constant presence, leading him to break down on several occasions including the unveiling of the war memorial at Glasgow High School, the school he left aged sixteen to enter the family banking business. According to the Dundee Evening Telegraph, his address honouring the bravery of the pupils who went overseas, including the 458 who never returned, brought Bonar Law to the verge of collapse.
His eldest son, James Kidston, then aged sixteen, joined up when war broke out. Charles John, his second son, soon followed in his brother’s footsteps, aged just seventeen when he joined the King’s Own Scottish Borderers. Close friends wrote of Charles in glowing terms, painting a picture of a modest officer, full of joy and enthusiasm, ‘one of the best’.
After his regiment was posted to Palestine, and shortly before the Battle of Gaza, Charles wrote to his father, hoping the action would be a success and they would ‘scupper’ the Turks. Three days later, he was reported missing. An early report by German newspaper suggested that Charles had been captured by the Turks. In June, the Vatican apparently verified this. Devastatingly for his father, the telegram received by the Vatican provided false comfort, omitting the vital word ‘not’ from the phrase ‘is a prisoner with the Turks’. Aged twenty, Charles had died of wounds three months earlier on 19 April 1917.
Later that year, Bonar Law suffered a further loss when Captain James Kidston’s plane was shot down in France on 21 September 1917. James’ body was never recovered and his name appears on the memorial to missing airmen at Arras. Lord Blake, Bonar Law’s biographer, stated that this second bereavement, coming so soon after the first, was an almost overwhelming blow, rendering the stricken Bonar Law incapable of work and causing him to resign as leader of the Conservative party.
After his death on 23 October 1923, to mark his brief post-war premiership from October 1922 to May 1923, Bonar Law’s ashes were interred at Westminster Abbey. A family memorial, inscribed with the names of father and sons, is found at Helensburgh - Bonar Law’s chosen resting place.