06/05/2026
If you look up land grants for Saint John NB that can be accessed at the Provincial Archives https://archives.gnb.ca/en-ca/collections/search you will see Parrtown and Carleton lots assigned by name to Loyalists.
đź—ş Before it became Saint John, the Port City was named Parrtown. The name was never very popular, in large part because Governor Parr had personally requested the city be named after himself, which the locals thought was rather gauche.
The 1784 Loyalists thought that was so gauche, in fact, that Parrtowners refused to call it Parrtown at all. Magistrate Edward Winslow commented in a letter: "The rude inhabitants of this new country have not yet acquired a sufficient degree of gallantry to indulge [Parr's] vanity."
Letters arrived in Halifax with pointed addresses — or lack thereof — reading things like: "the two towns now settling the Harbour — names unknown."
As Parrtown neared its one-year birthday, mailing addresses seemed to be converging on a new name: "Town On St. John's Harbour."
A popular movement to change the name arose and settled around "Carleton." This was not, however, honouring New Brunswick's first governor, Thomas Carleton.
The name was meant to honour the Governor of Quebec: Sir Guy Carleton. Not only had he been one of the few competent British leaders during the American Revolution, but Sir Guy was immensely popular with local Black Loyalists — he had personally intervened to help an estimated 3,000 of them escape after the war ended.
Black Loyalists were already calling their part of the harbour Carleton in Sir Guy's honour.
Across the water, Parrtowners liked the idea. They too wanted to honour Sir Guy. In what is surely the most bizarre naming convention ever proposed in the province's history, their movement landed on renaming their side of the harbour "Guy."
One side would be called Guy.
The other, Carleton.
Together, the city would be named "Guy Carleton."
"We can only be thankful wiser counsels prevailed," snarked historian W.O. Raymond.
In the end, they simply named the city after the harbour.
📍 Check out the stories behind more unusual New Brunswick place names here: backyardhistory.ca/f/some-unusual-place-names-in-new-brunswick